Understanding Real Estate Investing for Military
There are numerous ways to engage in real estate investing. There’s flipping, commercial offices, wholesaling, investing in notes, and the most popular among military families – residential rentals. Becoming a landlord may be the most popular form of real estate investing for military families by default. With steady incomes and incentives to buy houses heaped on service members, many become homeowners. When you own a house and receive military orders to another city your choices are limited. You either sell it, or you turn it into a rental property. Whether by plan or by fate, becoming a landlord is a solution often chosen.
Real estate investing also has a natural appeal to many military folks. Military families are do-it-yourself, ‘bootstrap’ people. There’s an air of self-determination around real estate investing. A sense that you are more in control of your destiny with real estate than you are with traditional investments.
Initiative and hard work seem like they can be turned into profit with a property on Main Street in a way that can not be realized with securities on Wall Street. Financial professionals describe it as inefficiencies in the real estate market that can be profitably exploited. I believe it is true, although more difficult to master than it seems.
The major obstacle to getting started in real estate investing is typically the initial cost. You can get started in TSP for 1% of your paycheck. With an app like Acorns you can open a brokerage account with your spare change.
To get into real estate investing takes capital, often tens of thousands of dollars of capital. It’s a big commitment.
Big financial commitments generate questions. Access to VA loans and other programs lowers the barriers to entry into real estate investing, but most military families have at least one member with enough sense to know you don’t spew cash at an idea like becoming a landlord without looking a little before you leap. I am asked about it frequently.
Following is a list of the seven most common questions I am asked by people who are contemplating investing in residential real estate rentals. Each of them probably merits its own article, but I’ll try to give you some useful short answers here.
Is real estate a good investment?
Let me break this news to you gently; it’s not about the real estate, it’s about you. Money can be made in real estate investing, but the path to it isn’t for everyone. In addition to technical know-how, a successful investor must have the ability to avoid frustration and derailment when people disappoint you. Because in residential rental real estate you have to deal with people, and people disappoint.
Sooner or later you will discover some tenants are vandals, some property managers are lazy idiots, and some contractors are thieves. If you believe the hype I see all over the internet about how easy it is to make money in real estate, you should not invest in real estate.
The successful landlords I know are hustling every day for their profits. The rest are trying to get back to even.
What are the tax benefits of real estate investing?
With respect to being a landlord, OWNING rental properties can have many tax benefits. SELLING rental properties usually has significant (and painful) tax consequences. Landlords are business owners. They own and operate residential real estate for the purposes of collecting rents.
The biggest expenditure in such a business is the cost of the property being let to the tenant(s). As a business owner, you can recover the cost of the buildings on your property by deducting them from your taxes over the lifetime of the building. This cost recovery process is known as ‘depreciation’, and its effects can make a tremendous impact to your bottom line while you own the building. However, if you sell the property you will likely owe the IRS for all the depreciation previously claimed on the building.
In addition to depreciation you can deduct all the ordinary and necessary operating expenses of a business. There are numerous ways to take advantage of this situation, but none of them will turn a bad investment into a good investment.
If you are thinking about getting into real estate investing do so because you want to make money from the investments and then take advantage of the tax benefits to maximize your profits. DO NOT get into real estate investing with the primary motive of reducing your taxes.
Why don’t financial advisors give real estate investing advice?
First – a few of us do. But, I get it. We are so difficult to find as to be indistinguishable from non-existent. Take heart, our numbers are growing! The primary reason there are so few of us is related to how the financial planning field evolved.
Financial planning, so the story goes, was the love child of a few insurance salesmen and stock brokers trying to do the right thing. All the first generation planners came from one of those two fields. You sold insurance and did financial planning or your sold stocks and did financial planning. Nobody sold real estate and did financial planning. The second generation of financial planners were nearly all “investment managers”. They took a piece of the action (a percentage) of all the assets they could gather and manage. Still no real estate.
The third wave is coming. In this wave we take a more holistic approach to financial planning. Some are even calling it ‘life planning’. Some advisors have observed that in life many people invest in real estate, so we are starting to include it in the plans we build with our clients. We are mostly self-taught, though. For example, the inclusion of real assets in a portfolio is not covered in the CFP (R) curriculum. (I am working to get that changed, btw.)
Should I form an LLC for my rental property?
Many people believe you must have your houses in an LLC to qualify for certain tax benefits. This is not true. There are no tax benefits to placing your rental properties in an LLC.
Zero.
None.
Your rental property business is a business whether it is within an LLC or not. Your ability to deduct business expenses is not impacted by forming an LLC.
There may be legal considerations for forming an LLC in terms of limiting your liability. That is a question for a lawyer. I am licensed to give tax advice. I am not licensed to give legal advice.
When is the best time to sell my rental property?
In terms of tax strategy – never. As I wrote above, OWNING rental properties can have significant tax benefits. SELLING rental properties frequently turns those significant benefits into significant burdens.
In many cases the most efficient tax strategy for rental properties is probate. When you die owning depreciated property your heirs inherit it with a cost basis reset to current market value. The tax burden is transferred to the government and is no longer a problem for you or your family.
If you absolutely must get rid of the property, then the second-best time to sell is likely today. The tax burden on the property is most likely going to grow over time, so getting rid of it now is like ripping off the band-aid. Just get it over with.
That said, every case is different. You should have a tax professional knowledgeable in real estate issues evaluate your situation before you act.
How does the ten-year extension for military people work?
Home sellers can exclude a significant amount of capital gain (frequently all the capital gain) from the sale of their primary residence as long as they meet certain guidelines. The short version of how to qualify for that exclusion is called the ‘2-in-5’ rule. You must live in the house for 2 of the 5 years immediately prior to the sale. There are additional rules, but those are the basics. That means you could move out of your house and turn it into a rental property for up to 3 years, then sell it, and still qualify for the exclusion from capital gains. (Because in the 5 years immediately preceding the sale you lived in the house for at least 2 of them.)
Military families receive up to an additional 10 years to this ‘2-in-5’ rule if they were moved more than 50 miles from the residence on military orders. This means military families could live in a house for 2 years, take a PCS move to another state, turn the house into a rental property and sell it up to 13 years later AND still qualify for the capital gains exclusion. It’s a pretty nifty benefit!
A related question I frequently get is ‘how long do we have if the military member retires while living at the other duty station?’. The answer is that once the service member retires the extended period stops. Military families receive UP TO 10 years. When you retire your extension stops and you essentially have 3 years from the retirement date to sell the property before you will have to pay capital gains on the sale.
My depreciation is wrong on my prior tax returns, how do I fix it?
The short answer is to hire a professional to do it for you.
The medium answer is that you can only fix a depreciation issue by amending returns if it was wrong on only one filed return. Once it’s been wrong on two filed tax returns you must submit an application to the IRS to change your method of accounting. This is done on form 3115, and it is a very complicated form. On the last page of the instruction book for form 3115 it estimates that it takes more than 36 hours to learn and prepare form 3115.
Save your time, hire a professional. If you prepared your own tax return and you didn’t get the depreciation right, then it is unlikely you will get form 3115 right.
The outcome of filing the form 3115 depends on how your depreciation was wrong. If you had been under depreciating the property, then you would get an adjustment allowing you to take a one-time additional beneficial depreciation adjustment on your tax return. (You get to claim an additional expense that year.)
If you had been over depreciating the property then you also get to take a depreciation adjustment to your tax return, but you won’t like it as much. The amount of over depreciation gets declared as additional income that year and you must pay tax on it. There are some strategy elements regarding the timing of these adjustments, so you should consult a tax professional knowledgeable in real estate investing before you act.
The Bottom Line
Real estate investing can be financially and emotionally satisfying when done well. At Redeployment Wealth Strategies we have some military families who are profiting nicely with their real estate investments. Unfortunately, we have a larger number of clients who got on that real estate investing highway before they thoroughly researched their situation, and now they’re looking for the off-ramp.
We urge you to carefully consider whether real estate investing is right for you before you make that large capital commitment to participate. Learning the hard way can be very expensive.
As financial advisors, members of the MFAA help people just like you navigate the questions, challenges, and planning opportunities related to investing in real estate. We would love to be of help and have a free consultation.
